Hillary Clinton
At first glance, Ezra Klein's idea makes a certain kind of sense:
The Senate is likely to be friendlier when confirming one of its own.... I've always been partial to the idea of seeing Hillary Clinton appointed to the Supreme Court. She's got a law degree, of course. She's practiced law, practiced politics and practiced statecraft. She's been present in both the executive and the legislative branch. She's done an enormous amount of retail politics, which I think is useful. She's smart and hardworking and has proven herself adaptable to a wide range of institutions.
Klein adds: "The counterargument I got on Twitter is that she's controversial, but I'm not sure I really believe that anymore. She's well-known, and many Republicans in the Senate like her personally."
Whoa. True, as senator Hillary got along well enough with her GOP colleagues. But a SCOTUS nomination isn't a congeniality contest. Republican senators are hell-bent on increasing their ranks in this fall's elections. And they will not hesitate to use confirmation hearings as a way to motivate independent voters whose disdain for Hillary rivals that of Obama. She would appear under oath, and last time she was in that position she came within an inch of indictment for perjury — that favorite Clinton pastime. Is she ready to revisit nagging questions about Whitewater and the Rose billing records — and a whole lot more — at televised hearings where "I don't recall" wouldn't cut it?
Perhaps she'd be willing to go through all that one more time, given suggestions that as secretary of state she's been marginalized by Obama and his foreign policy inner circle. She may decide it's worth going through the hell of very tough questions for the payoff of a lifetime Court seat. Once she dons the black robe, she'd be free to legislate from the bench and would never have to answer to anyone for the rest of her public life. You've got to think that's Hillary Clinton's idea of heaven.
First things first: Obama would have to nominate her. Not likely. He knows her baggage better than anyone. After the bruising health-care vote, Obama doesn't need another high-stakes partisan battle just as the midterm elections are heating up. He'd be smart to nominate a (somewhat) moderate jurist. Merrick Garland is one candidate who fits the bill.




